Our 16 Best Apple Pies And Tarts That Would Make Grandma Proud

Test Kitchen Tip: To score perfectly golden results, tent the pie with foil for the final 30 minutes of baking so the crust doesn’t burn. Buy It: Sander’s Caramel Topping ($4, Target) Test Kitchen Tip: To save time on day-of prep, start with store-bought puff pastry and whip up the apple filling up to 24 hours in advance before you assemble, bake, and devour.